This is a 1-hour session where we review our client’s documents and give them feedback on where their papers – personal statement, CV/CAAPID applications, and if requested letters of recommendations and other supplemental essays they’ve submitted as well, with the understanding that reviewing those would take away time from discussing their main essay and CV. We promise to review their papers, but at times the conversation will also include candidacy as well – clients will often ask questions related to it, asking what else they should do to improve their profile.
Clients generally use this session for
1. Reviewing documents used during a past application cycle if it didn’t go so well, to troubleshoot
2. Review documents they’ve worked on – either on their own or with the help of a non-IDC professional – to get our opinion on it before applying for the current cycle
By the end of the session the client should
1. Know where their papers stand
2. Understand the importance of a well-crafted application (which is different from having a strong profile)
*Please review documents the clients submitted prior to meeting them.
*The meeting may last for up to 1 hour minutes.
*Get in the habit of giving the client a heads up on when the session needs to be wrapped up especially if the client has a lot of questions. At a certain point letting them know that you have another meeting in 15 minutes, so what are some things you want to make sure we discuss? Is a good way to do this.
*If their applications could benefit from a professional touch, let them know we have editors here that have been working with our clients for a long time. They do get really busy Jan-April and often there’s a waitlist to get started during that time. Link to send them if they’re interested: https://editing.internationaldentistcentral.com/
*During the session take notes here: https://team.internationaldentistcentral.com/notes/client-session-notes/
*After the session, an email will be automatically generated from you to the client with the notes you included for them using the Client Notes form.
Next step for the client:
Do nothing – sometimes their papers are good, and if that’s the case let them know!
If working with us – we have editing in a basic and more involved capacity. Get more info here: https://editing.internationaldentistcentral.com/packages/
If needed, suggest a coaching session (if they have lots of questions about what they shoud be doing for their profile)
About our clients
Our clients often focus on the question ‘what can I do to improve my profile?’ over ‘how can I present myself in a more competitive manner?’. This is NOT to underplay the importance of candidacy and a competitive profile, because it IS important, but equally important especially to the average candidate is how they present themselves; it’s not just about finding the next thing they can do to add to their profiles.
- Our clients have never written admissions essays before. Where they come from, they just submitted test scores and would either get accepted or not. This is all new and it can be hard to grasp the importance of it.
- They think a CV is just a list of their accomplishments, rather than an argument for why they’re qualified. They don’t take writing the details of each experience very seriously.
- Every step of this application/admissions process costs a lot of money For those coming in from abroad it seems especially more expensive – approximately $300 for each program just in fees – so they often try to save where they can. This is ironic because a mediocre application will almost certainly guarantee they won’t make it in, and they’ll have to do it all over again next year.
- They think the American dentist they work with, or their friend who got accepted into a program is a great person to give them feedback on their papers. We don’t think they are.
How we explain things to clients
We think there are 2 kinds of people who are qualified to give advice on admissions papers
1. Those who have experience serving in college/grad school admissions committees
2. Those who’ve worked with many candidates, and therefore read a LOT of papers.
The dentist they work with is NOT it – dentists are generally not good writers, and they’ve gone through this process much too long ago and haven’t had to write anything like this for a very long time. They’re not in touch with what’s good and what’s not, and how other applicants’ papers read.
And their friend who got accepted into a program? we don’t know if they got accepted due to or in spite of their papers. And how are THEY supposed to know how other applicant’s papers read?
When they apply to programs, the committee doesn’t get to see the actual applicant, just the papers as a representation of the applicant. If they don’t like you on paper they won’t bring you in for an interview, it’s that simple. This is a competitive program. So your papers need to be more convincing and better than other people’s papers for you to be considered especially if you’re an average candidate. I know you’re not average, you’re a dentist and worked hard to get there, but unfortunately so is everyone else applying. It’s really hard.
Put simply, we can plot candidate’s profiles on a bell-curve. Those towards the top will likely garner interest even if they don’t pay as much attention to thier essays and stuff, but for the majority, everyone’s profile looks similar to one another. This is where the real competition is, and to stand out from that bunch you need to pay a lot of attention to how you’re presenting yourself through those documents. Some with average candidacy will get called, but not all. Your profile can look exactly the same as someone else’s – how is the program going to choose who to interview and who not to? Through the documents! Your essay is a blank piece of paper you can utilize to express yourself, and hopefully by the end of reading it the reader is interested in you.
Personal Statement
It’s a good idea to work with someone who has experience working with people from our community, especially on their personal statement. This is because their origin story can look very unique to the eyes of an outsider, yet be totally cliche to those who know our clientele.
Please review this page to see example personal statements and our standards for it: https://team.internationaldentistcentral.com/articles/6-personal-statements/
CV/CAAPID
CAAPID stands for Centralized Application for Advanced Placement for International Dentists. It’s an online portal where applicants input data that would be written inside a CV as well as their personal statement. Supplemental applications for individual programs may or may not be submitted through CAAPID (some programs ask applicants to mail it in directly), and not all programs participate in CAAPID.
Generally, when applicants talk about it though, they’re referring to the CV portion of it as it’s what makes up the bulk of CAAPID.
It’s important for clients to know that the ‘description’ section of CAAPID where you get to describe your experience as you see fit is important, and you don’t waste that space with the mundane, boring and obvious. One notable area for this is in their dental assisting experience. An assistant’s job comes with setup, breakdown, and sterilization of equipment. This doesn’t need to be explained, yet most applicants will list this on the very top space in the description section when discussing what their duties were. You want them to, instead, think of anything unique they brought to the table and write those out instead. Think of the reader, do your best to not give them yet another boring CV to read.
Of course, grammar, tense, and style being coherent throughout should go without saying.
Profile
Even though this is NOT what we promise to go through in the package, the conversation will almost always get steered in this direction. This is something I like to always explain to whomever I have this conversation with
Any experience that’s easy to obtain will NOT carry much weight and will NOT make your application stand out. Those important experiences take time to build, there’s no small hack you can do to give your profile a strong push.
Also there’s no right or wrong.
If the client seems to be hung up on their profile, asks difficult to answer questions or whatnot, please recommend that they do a coaching session with either Dr. Alyssa or Kevin to discuss this further, as this session is to discuss documents itself and maybe go over basic things about their candidacy but not really to strategize it in-depth. Here’s a link you can send them: https://internationaldentistcentral.com/hourly-services/
That being said, here’s what to look for when discussing profiles.
THe typical candidate
From India
3.7 GPA
1-2 years clinical experience before moving to the U.S.
Passed both NBDE 1&2 in the first attempt
TOEFL 104
U.S. dental assisting eperience for a few months to a few years, depending on how long the candidate was here for.
Is wondering what they can do to improve their profile.
GPA
GPAs from India are generally inflated, over 3.5 considered good. Other countries can have their own standard and asking what percentage they were in class will give you a better idea, sometimes the GPA will be low yet they were very good students, and at times this needs to be discussed somewhere else in their application. ECE is supposed to give us a reliable GPA but it doesn’t, and programs know this.
Academic Ability and NBDE attempts
Schools are accepting international dentists to come into their program to become students again, so bringing in people that will be good students is important. Things that support this is: GPA from dental school, GPA from grad school (US or international), and failed NBDE attempts.
For NBDE, unlike TOEFL, when you request a report be sent out to a program, lists all of your failed attempts at the test if you have them. Passing them in 1 go doesn’t make your profile strong, but failing is not good.
A place where I suggest considering doing a master’s program in the US is when a candidate’s academic ability just seems low – low GPA, failed board attempts, etc. You need to redeem yourself.
NBDE is a pass/fail exam, and most candidates take both part I and part II before applying. It’s recommended to do this, but it only puts you to average if you do.
TOEFL
Shoot for over 100. Under 95 is weak. From this one score they’ll judge your English, this is a big deal in an English speaking program. You’ll be communicating with patients in the program too.
Your past scores will NOT be sent to schools, you can take it as many times as you need and they’ll never know. It’s a cheap test that only takes a few hours to take, so just try as many times as you need.
Residency/Specialty Training
This training is usually done in their home country and it elevates an applicant’s candidacy a lot. Just because they’re a specialist from abroad doesn’t mean they should say in their application that they want to specialize again in the same department – no right or wrong, just need to be explain your point of view and your why.
Master’s in the u.S.
Often applicants will get a Master’s degree in the U.S. for the purpose of strengthening their candidacy. This is fine, and it’s recommended if the applicant doesn’t have much to show regarding their academic ability.
Whether they should get a master’s is a question often asked – if they need to redeem their ability to be a good student, I say yes. Otherwise I say it depends – I mean it takes 2 years to go through this, could you do other stuff in those 2 years to strengthen you candidacy? Probably, but what part of your cadidacy you should be working on depends, so it’s not a straightforward answer.
I do say this though – go for a good school, and NO online programs please. Once you’re in work hard, many clients shared how much work it was to get a good GPA in the program. If your GPA is bad this is just going to reinforce the fact that you’re not that great of a student. And once you’re in build relationships, you want a STRONG recommendation letter coming from the program. Also try and get involved in research projects while you’re a student, it’ll be easier than trying to get into research labs as an outsider. But getting accepted at a master’s program is just the beginning, and you can do a lot from it if you decide. But please make the 2 years you’re spending there worth it.
Clinical Experience
Experience a client has treating patients – so not in the US working as a dental assistant or even a hygienist, though hygiene experience in the US is great.
Internship that was required to get their dental license does NOT count, it was just part of education.
No experience: not good but pretty common.
1-3 years: average
3+ uears: much better
Teaching experience
It’s not uncommon for dentists that have been faculty abroad to come here as well. It’s generally a positive experience, but the experience has to be presented in a thoughtful way.
Keep in mind that this person is trying to be a student again in the U.S., and practicioners/teachers who are set in their ways can be difficult to mold and teach. The people teaching them here can have less experience than the student, so it can make for a weird dynamic. Don’t be the intimidating applicant that knows it all.
Research
Not all research is created equal, please don’t list a questionnaire project you did in dental school under Research Experience – programs are looking for projects that take longer, real research projects. If you’ve got a published paper that’s awesome!
Some clients get involved with research in the US, either getting started in a Master’s program or somehow getting their foot in the door and starting out as an assistant. The level of involvement they had is different for each situation, which means the level of impact it will have in one’s candidacy is also different.
But even if they were a research assistant, still good experience. We’d want to see a recommendation letter coming from the lead researcher.
Recommendation Letters
CAAPID allows 3 submissions, and many programs allow more to be uploaded. 1 of those 3 need to come from the dean of the dental school the candidate graduated from. Deans don’t know students very well, so this letter is more of a formality, a checkbox.
About the other 2 – it can be difficult to decide who they should come from. You want to consider the highlights of one’s candidacy and also their future goals in making this decision. Also generally, letters that come from North America carry more weight and are viewed more trustworthy than those coming from abroad, as recommendation letters are not a part of the culture where most of our clients come from.
If applicant did a master’s program in the US, one should come from there.
One letter from a US dentist is also a good idea – one they worked with > volunteered for > shadowed.
If they have research experience in the US, one coming from the lab is also expected.
Sometimes we’ll have to make decisions to drop one due to the CAAPID limit, and this should be done with the general candidacy in mind.
Volunteer Experience
Almost everyone has dental camp experience from dental school.
Volunteering as a dental assistant at a for-profilt private office doesn’t really count as volunteering, as it wasn’t for the good of the community and candidates do this because their visa status doesn’t allow them to work. But help them understand what volunteering means in the U.S. culture.
And if they’re lacking it in their profile, encourage the to get some. It doesn’t have to be dental related, though it can be.
U.S. dental experience
Not everyone can work here due to their visa/immigration status, but having a paid position is a plus.
Having some dental experience is to be expected, it’s not really a plus in one’s profile. You should see how dental office are ran in the U.S. to see if that’s what you want to do in your career, right?
If you’re plannig on specializing, try to get some experience from that specialty you want to go into.
Preceptorship Programs
Some dental schools have preceptorship programs in specialty departments that lead to certificates for internationally trained dentists. The characteristics of each program vary greatly. They are, honestly, often a money-making program for the programs.
A typical one will last 3 months or so and students will mainly observe the residents treating patients. They’ll take part in lectures that residents take, and have another project of their own that leads to a presentation of some kind.
Some will be longer, and in some rare cases they treat patients – the Restorative Dentistry preceptorship program of UCLA is a notable one, but it’s 1 year long. This program is a huge plus for obvious reasons.
A typical program is still a plus in one’s candidacy, especially if the applicant is wanting to specialize – then they should try to do a program in that specialty.